When The Argument Serves a Purpose


I am no therapist, nor am I a subject matter expert by any means. But what I am is a woman that has been married three times, and while I may think I have it figured out now, I’m still growing. The following is simply what I have learned so far about arguing, and what I probably could still learn.

People Argue

First of all – people argue. A couple that doesn’t argue is simply a couple that is either avoiding each other, not in love anymore (going through the motions), or are so emphatically in love and beyond perfect for each other that it is almost sickening (see True Love – Westley and Buttercup). What draws to one another are similarities in interests and personalities, in addition to the differences that we can learn from one another. I know if I dated myself I would drive myself crazy. What I like in a partner are the similarities that are important to me (I have my list) and a few interests and personality traits that offset mine.

 “A healthy argument can clarify each partner’s needs and allow each to maintain his or her own sense of personal integrity within the relationship. In other words, each person can hold on to the qualities which made him or her attractive to the other in the first place. The difference between a happy and an unhappy relationship is often due to how the partners argue.” – Dr. Maynard Brussman

What ‘s important is that the argument maintain a level of respect and achieve an accomplishment. Whether it be a common behavior that might upset the other that is talked out respectfully (no name calling, blaming, demeaning, etc) and the couple both learn from each other moving forward with an actionable plan. The reality of that actually happening is slim to none. In fact the ratio of positive interactions to negative in happy couples is 20 to 1, in conflicted couples is 5 to 1, and in soon-to-divorce couples is .8 to 1. It takes two people to argue, and while one may maintain respectfulness and work towards a goal, the other has to be one the same path in order for the argument to truly be effective.


The Relationship Is NOT Doomed

Ironically, as I write this post it is day of my parent’s 50th wedding anniversary. I have watched my parents argue through the years – from large arguments (my Father leaving the dinner table to eat in his Den) lasting, at times, for days to bickering over the little things that are over before the rest of the room realizes they are even arguing.

Arguments and disagreements are not necessarily a sign of a failed relationship or that love is fading . They are often just a sign that the partners are expressing their own individuality, and this is healthy. It helps to ask whether the arguments usually lead in a downward spiral toward bitterness and stalemate or whether they lead to better communication and greater intimacy.

Dr. Maynard Brussman

I have watched my parents go from them not talking for days with obvious anger in their early years to recent slight raised voice and a “That’s enough” from either that stops the other dead in their tracks. Clearly at various points throughout the years my parents have talked things out, come to compromises, worked out what respect is to each other, and now exercise what they have learned. I can only hope that my Husband and I follow down the same path and end up with an understanding for one another and level of respect that only years of listening and compromising can accomplish.

Keys To Constructive Arguing

Combining my experience in failed marriages, working with countless therapists during those marriages, and completing my own research I have gathered a list of ways in which a couple can argue respectfully and constructively.

  • Starting off Calm – before you start addressing your concern with your partner, it is best to ensure that you are calm and your partner is calm. This way you are able to rationally address the situation and your partner will be in the best mood to receive what is about to be said.
  • Take Responsibility – be sure to understand your part in any argument or discussion. Being able to say “Ok, I guess I’m partly responsible.” Or say, “I guess I didn’t help the situation by….” will open the dialogue and set the example that you are both on the same playing field.
  • Don’t Try To Be Right - When we approach an argument with the belief that someone is right and the other is wrong, then the person put in the position of being wrong ends up on the defensive. There is no right or wrong, only understanding and compromise.
  • The Impact on Your Partner - Arguments are usually started because of miss-communication or a simple misunderstanding. Your partner may blame you for starting an argument when that is the last thing you had in mind. Be aware of what your partner is trying to say when they are upset, hurt, or frustrated with you.
  • You Can’t Change The Past –  Although you may feel hurt by something that happened in the past, the only options people have are to work towards the future. Of course, you may want to talk about things which have bothered you in the past, but holding a grudge usually interferes with the productive resolution of current problems. Work on one current problem at a time, not a list of things from the past, and try to discuss the problem while it is relevant.
  • State Your Needs in a Positive Manner -  It is not helpful to criticize the person’s character; this simply puts the other person on the defensive. Labeling the person with words like “crazy,” “immature,” or “slob” does not solve the specific problem you need to address, and it ensures that you will not be heard. These words are only meant to hurt (and it would be better in this case just to say, “Right now I feel like I want to hurt your feelings”). Let your partner know that it is a specific behavior that bothers you, and behaviors can be changed— especially when there is a commitment to the relationship.
  • Effective Communication - Use “I-statements”: when you want to convey how you feel. Take responsibility for your own feelings and assume that your partner is responsible for his or her own. Instead of starting the statement with a finger point and “You…” try expressing how you feel while addressing what it is that your partner can do to help.
  • Take a Time Out – This is something I learned very early on in my first marriage and has stayed with me throughout the years as a very useful tool. When I see the situation getting out of control as anger is building, words are being used to hurt, or even getting physical, it is a good time to take a moment to calm down and come back when you both can be rational and respectful. Calling the time out must be respected and honored, and a time to revisit the conversation should be established so that you both know this won’t be swept under the rug and ignored. If it’s a few minutes, hour, or a day or two – be respectful of each other’s space and time you both need to heal from the argument. When you come back remember to follow the rules of productive arguing and agree on a common goal from the discussion.
Of course expecting that you both follow the guidelines of productive arguing is asking a lot, but getting into the habit of following them as much as possible will allow for a healthier argument and relationship. Remember, no one is perfect and slip ups will happen – they key is to be respectful of one another and agree on what the outcome should be.

Counterproductive Arguing

Just as there is productive means to an argument, there are quite a lot of ways in which an argument can go south very quickly. Understanding the key behaviors than can be counterproductive within yourself can help you on the path to a healthier relationship. Remember to understand these within yourself – not pointing the blame by saying “Oh he does that…” or “That’s her to the T.” If you can recognize in yourself what of the following you have a tendency towards will allow you to live a happier life in general. Not to mention that your partner will appreciate the effort.


  • Escalating - Moving from the basic issue to questioning your partners personality then question if the relationship is worth it is counterproductive. Trying to gain the upper hand with escalating the argument to a whole new level could only potentially turn the situation into something you could very well regret.
  • Timing - Finding the right time to bring up an issue with your partner is crucial. Choosing to start a discussion while they are watching TV, getting ready for bed, or first getting up in the morning are not optimal times to start up a serious talk. When your partner is ready to engage in a serious discussion you both will benefit.
  • Crucializing - Try not to exaggerate the issue into the relationship as a whole. Saying things like “If you loved me, you would never have done this”. Focus on the discussion at hand and the goal of resolving through respect.
  • Brown Bagging – Maintain focus on the issue at hand without pouring on every past issue ever discussed all at the same time. An overwhelmed person can never fight back effectively and it only distracts from the current issue never really resolving it. Then adding it to the pile of issues to be loaded for next time. You will never get anything resolved, and the end result is just a failed relationship.
  • Asking Why – Simply starting with the word “why” can result in the other person feeling like they are being treated like a child. You are both adults, and therefore should respect one another like adults.
  • Cross Complaining - When your partner brings up an issue, don’t pile on a similar one to theirs. There is no tit for tat, only distracting from the discussion and not resolving the issue.
  • Over-Generalizing – Using words like “never” or “always” only throws your partner into the defensive and will escalate the argument. Be respectful and focus on the issue as it is to be addressed and offer up a solution or compromise.
  • Blaming - Remember it takes two to make a relationship work. Blaming your partner for the failed relationship and never accepting responsibility for your own actions is only going to drive them away.
  • Using Sarcasm – Be aware of the tone of your voice and the words you choose to go with it. Saying things like “Well, lookee here at who’s so perfect all the time!” are only going to put your partner on the defensive and is counterproductive to what you would like to accomplish from the argument.
  • Mind Reading – Telling your partner how they feel is denying them their rights as an equal and will only cause the argument to get worse never resolving anything. Instead focus on how you feel and allow them to express their emotions when they feel they can effectively.
  • Fortune Telling – Similar to mind reading fortune telling is telling your partner that they are going to do something before they have had a chance to do it. Anything from making another mistake, saying something in the near or distant future, or telling them they are going to react a certain way only escalates the argument and distracts from the purpose of the discussion.
  • Pulling Rank – Treat your partner as an equal. Telling them that because you do more around the house, or make more money only puts them in a position below you. You are both adults and equal partners in this relationship.
  • Not Listening – Pay attention and fully understand what it is your partner is trying to tell you is important. Only picking up on part of the conversation and throwing it in their face, pretending to read or watch TV, or just walking out of the house when an issue is brought up only leave the problem unresolved.
  • Giving Advice – Trying to be helpful and offering up advice when your partner brings up an issue only demeans what it is your partner is really trying to say. Instead listen and absorb as much as you can with understanding.
  • Labeling - Using words  like “neurotic,” “alcoholic,” “immature,” or “paranoid” to label your partner are only going to put them on the defensive. Instead try addressing the issue as it is rather than labeling them.
  • Avoiding Responsibility – Accept your responsibility in the issue that is brought up. Dismissing the discussion by saying “I forgot” or “I must have had too much to drink” is only going to stop the argument before anything is resolved.
  • Playing the Martyr - “You’re right, honey, I guess there really is no hope for me.” How can your partner respond to that? Or pretending to be sick until your partner’s behavior changes— and blaming your illness on your partner is only going to distract from the issue. Focus on what they are saying and work together to resolve it.
  • Rejecting Compromise – In the game of arguing there is no real true winner. Instead of sticking to your guns and refusing to compromise, try listening and compromise as a couple.

The Four Horsemen

four horsemen blog pic 3Gottman’s Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse an Marital Meltdown identifies four main “toxic behaviors” which contribute directly to couples feeling disconnected, isolated and distant from each other. When couples have a high frequency of these toxic behaviors, isolation and loneliness increases. These “cascades of isolation and loneliness”  increases the likelihood of marital meltdown and contribute strongly to the likelihood of divorce.


  1. Criticism - When you criticize your partner you are basically implying that there is something wrong with them. You take a complaint too far. It’s one thing to point out a specific behavior that is bothering you. It’s another thing to generalize your complaint to include aspects of your partner’s person. Instead focus on the issue itself and leave your partner out of it. Even if it is something they said or did – understand it was most likely not done intentionally and can be addressed respectfully.
  2. Defensiveness - When you attempt to defend yourself from a perceived attack with a counter complaint you are being defensive.  Sometimes people think defensiveness is warranted because “the other person started it” by using a harsh attack. Actually, defensiveness is just another way to shift the blame onto one’s partner. Defensiveness is about offering excuses in order to avoid responsibility.Instead try listening to what your partner is trying to say. If you feel you are starting to get on the defensive track, then ask for a time out and let them know you will be ready to openly discuss it in an hour or so. Then be ready to really own what it is that is being addressed and discuss it in a rational manner.
  3. Contempt - Contempt is any statement or nonverbal behavior that puts yourself on a higher ground than your partner. This is the worst of the Horseman because it’s hard to work through a problem when the only vibe you’re getting from you’re partner is that they are disgusted with you. Or when you’re convinced your partner is an idiot (as the one showing disgust). Contempt usually comes from a “holier than thou” place. Try focusing on your tone and choice of words while discussing the issue with your partner. Treat them as an equal and work together towards resolution.
  4. Stonewalling - Stonewalling happens when the listener withdraws from the conversation. After several rounds of criticism, contempt, and defensiveness, stonewalling can come into play. This happens when one partner tunes out. This partner will stop talking, look away, and even stay very still. This usually means that the partner is overwhelmed with the negativity and doesn’t know any other way to soothe. Stonewalling doesn’t work in relationships because it ends the conversation before the couple are able to navigate their way through the conflict. If you feel overwhelmed try asking for a time out, or simply let your partner know that you have reached your limit. Explain that the negativity is more than you can handle and you either need a break, or would benefit from a more productful means of discussing the issue.

In watching the video I see some of my past and even current behaviors in how I argue with my Husband. See if you can recognize the behavior in yourself.


The Ability To Argue

Some people are simply just unable to argue. As the Dr. Maynard Brusman put it:

 Some people are unable to argue because they feel that their underlying anger, which can get triggered during an argument, will go out of control . Others find it difficult to argue since they feel inadequate within the relationship. Some were exposed to bitter arguments as they grew up so that they don’t want to repeat the pattern of their unhappy parents during their own adulthood. When people just hate to argue, for whatever reason, they frequently make up prematurely without resolving the issue in order to avoid conflict. Or they may resort to fighting unfairly to gain power over and distance themselves from their partner instead of coming to a compromise and strengthening their commitment to the relationship. When goodwill and trust are damaged, the probability of using dirty fighting techniques increases. If a relationship reaches the point where arguments are frequent and damaging, the couple probably needs to make a commitment to resolve the problem and to try more productive methods of relating on difficult topics. - Dr. Maynard Brussman

Seeking a counselor or therapist to help you through relationship therapy, you and your partner can focus in part on establishing new communication patterns, aims to facilitate the goal of resolving the issue.

I have been through arguments that have both resolved effectively and respectfully and ones that have escalated beyond control. Now that I am older (and getting wiser) I now feel I have a good sense of the steps I should be taking to resolve an issue with my Husband. If you feel that there is no resolution, or that your not arguing effectively, it is always good to seek out a professional to aid in your resolution. In the meantime, I hope this was helpful in your journey to be a more productful arguer. Feel free to share your experience, or anything you would like to add in the comments below.

Resources (because there’s no way I could have come up with all of this on my own):

Arguing With Your Partner – Ways to Lose and Ways to Win - Dr. Maynard Brusman

Destructive Arguing – Marriage and Family Clinic

Gottman Couples & Marriage Therapy

You Are Responsible for your Happiness


I just got off the phone with a very near and dear friend of mine I have known since the 2nd grade. She and her Husband have been having trouble and she needed a friend to bounce some thoughts off of. There was a statement she made, that ironically another friend had mentioned in the form of a question the other day (in regards to her Marriage), and yet another friend (a guy this time) had mentioned about his wife several months ago that really struck a cord with me. I don’t know why I tend to be the giver of advice (or why people seek it) being the twice divorced Mom of two who’s third Husband currently lives in another state, but nonetheless I have plenty of advice to give. Whether it is good advice or not – well I’ll let you decide.

The statement was “He should make me happy.

My response:

Your Husband is NOT Responsible for your Happiness… You Are.


So many of us look to others to “make us happy”. When what we should be doing is looking within ourselves to find our own happiness. This piece of advice that I give comes from two perspectives. First from being the person expected to make the other person happy. Second from my own perspective and my own happiness.


Expectations of Providing Happiness


My first Husband was (and still is) someone that is very unhappy. He has his moments of happiness, don’t get me wrong. He has activities he does, a home that is his very much his own (and fits him well), and our children that he finds joy in. But his overall happiness and the joy in the little things of life just aren’t quite there. I can’t speak for how he is now as he has a girlfriend that provides the happiness he seeks, but while we were married I can attest to what was expected of me as a wife. Dinner was expected every evening… Therefore dinner was provided every evening. But that wasn’t enough. It had to be a protein, a veggie, and a starch. So, I made sure it was a well balanced meal. I’m not a big fan of a lot of veggies, so at times I would run out of ideas for a veggie and perhaps just leave them out. Sometimes we didn’t have money for pasta or potatoes and the starch would be missing. I didn’t get in trouble right then, but eventually a break down would occur and I would get grief for not providing a well balanced meal regularly.


Now there are many other examples, but this is just one that most couples go through. It’s not the right kind of foods, maybe there is something served that they other person doesn’t like on occasion, or whatever it is. Then during an emotional breakdown the blanket statement of “She doesn’t make the dinners that I like.” comes into play. It can really be anything like “He isn’t home enough, and when he is he is on the ___.” (insert Xbox, computer, phone, etc) , or “She is so busy with the kids she doesn’t have time for me.”


Do you see that the person the complaint is about really does make an effort. They hear the complaint, and want badly for the other person to be happy. The problem lies in the person that demands the happiness. I could never win the game of happiness, and I am sure no one is able to win it. Because the happiness lies within the person that so badly wants to be happy. My parting words to my Husband when I left (among many parting words) were “I hope you find your happiness…” because not only was I tired of trying to make him happy and felt like it was a un-achievable task of which it was best to give up and walk away, but it was so emotionally draining to constantly be failing that it destroyed me. I was not only a failure in myself, but I was a failure in the eyes of the man I loved dearly and needed that approval from. My only solution was to leave.


To this day I am very selective of the company I keep. People that expect me to provide their happiness are cast aside, and those that are just who they intend to be, are held close. If someone starts looking to me for solutions to their problems, or expect me to do something to make them happy are quickly held at a very long arms length. It is what keeps me sane, grounded, and healthy – and I do hope they will find their happiness some day. I just am not the one to provide it.


My Own Happiness


Just as I was expected to provide happiness for another, I too must remember that I am responsible for my own happiness. As the years of being on my own with two children passed I began to rely on myself for my needs, wants, and desires. Mother’s Day was always the biggest one for me. You see, when a woman has two very small children and Mother’s Day rolls around with no Husband to take the kids out to buy gifts for her or encourage the kids to give her a day where she feels special, then… well… it doesn’t happen. So who do I have to rely on to provide that happiness? Well… myself. So one year I flew to Mexico and spent Mother’s Day on the beach while my kids were with their Father. You see – I provided my own happiness.


Expecting the other person to provide you with that happiness you seek is only going to put strain and frustration on your relationship. Significant other, Spouse, or even friendships can quickly fall apart if the other feels pressure to provide happiness and fails (because you know they will).


Now that I am married again, there is no expectation on him (or myself) to provide the other with happiness. Dinner gets done when it can get done. It is made of what is available in the house. Everyone eats, is well fed and happy. My Husband and I have little rituals we have developed together, but none are ever expected. If we break a ritual (as we often have) then we move onto another one. No one is upset, no one brings it up later as a blanket statement “You don’t do this…” We don’t expect the other to make us happy – we just are. Well… there are times we aren’t, I mean, we are Human after all. But we don’t get angry at the other for the unhappiness (for too long anyways). I myself look at my unhappiness, figure out why I am feeling unhappy. I will then come up with a solution to bring happy back – and I execute that solution.


Unhappiness is a Lot of Work


A New York Times Article “Happiness Inc.” states:

To clear the haze, Dr. Lyubomirsky spent that decade trying to define what happy and unhappy people were like. According to her friend Andrew Ward, now in the psychology department at Swarthmore College, “the working assumption in those years was that happy people were rationalizing all the time.” So Dr. Lyubomirsky designed an experiment in which people ranked 10 desserts, knowing they’d get one. Each participant was then given his second or third choice and told to rank all 10 desserts again. Guess who rationalized the desserts they received? The unhappy people. As Dr. Ward remembered, “The happy people said, ‘Well, this dessert is good, and I’m sure the others are good, too!’ The unhappy people liked their desserts just fine but indicated they were extremely relieved not to have received the ‘awful’ nonchosen dessert. In other words, unhappy people derogated the dessert they did not receive, whereas happy people felt no need to do so. The implication is that unhappy people are doing more mental work.”

So try to find your own happiness. Not only will it be beneficial for your own health, it will be beneficial in your relationships as well. And don’t try to be someone else’s happiness. You will never be able to accomplish it, and it will only lead to stress on yourself.


I leave you with this parting quote from the article:

“I remember when I was writing the chapter about relationships in ‘The Myths of Happiness,’ ” she said. “One day when I was driving home I finally thought: ‘Oh! I should do something nice for my husband this week.’ ”